Why Are People Leaving Florida for Michigan? The Surprising Truth
- Andrew McManamon
- Jun 2
- 7 min read
When you think of Florida, it’s easy to conjure up images of endless sunshine, sandy beaches, and retirees enjoying their golden years. Michigan, on the other hand, might bring to mind snowy winters, auto manufacturing and potholes. Yet, data reveals a trend that might surprise you: thousands of people are leaving the Sunshine State for the Great Lakes State. What’s going on? Why would anyone trade palm trees for pine trees? The answer is more complex than you might think.
Moving From Florida To Michigan
Florida To Michigan Migration
According to the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2022 American Community Survey, Florida was one of the top states sending residents to Michigan. Over 17,500 people made the journey north in 2022 alone. This is part of a broader trend in domestic migration that reveals shifting priorities for American families. Interestingly, this migration isn’t limited to retirees or specific demographics. Younger families, professionals, and even business owners are among those making the move. The decision to leave Florida for Michigan often stems from a combination of economic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that are becoming increasingly important in today’s world. Living in Florida may seem like living the dream, but dig a little deeper, and you’ll find cracks in the sunny façade.
Here are some of the top reasons why people decide to pack up and head north:
Florida has become a victim of its own popularity. The influx of new residents and out-of-state investors has driven up housing costs significantly. The median home price in Florida soared to over $400,000 in 2023, with hotspots like Miami and Tampa seeing even higher spikes. In addition to housing, other costs like insurance and property taxes have risen sharply. Home insurance premiums in Florida are now among the highest in the nation, with an average annual cost of $4,231, compared to the national average of $1,544. Flood insurance, a necessity in many parts of the state, adds another financial burden. Compare that to Michigan, where housing is more affordable and insurance premiums are considerably lower, and you can see why financially savvy individuals are reconsidering their options. (Who wouldn’t trade a $4,000 insurance bill for a snow shovel?)
Florida’s frequent hurricanes aren’t just a nuisance; they’re a serious threat to safety and property. In 2022 alone, Florida experienced three named storms, causing billions in damages. Many residents find themselves in a cycle of rebuilding, dealing with insurance claims, and living in constant fear of the next storm. Michigan, on the other hand, offers a natural haven. While the winters can be tough, the state is largely free from natural disasters like hurricanes, earthquakes, or wildfires. For some, the trade-off of snow shoveling over hurricane evacuations is worth it. Plus, you’ll never hear the weather report announce a "Snowpocalypse" with quite the same drama.
Moving From Florida To Michigan
Florida Vs. Michigan Population
Florida’s population boom has led to overcrowded schools, congested highways, and longer wait times for everything from doctor’s appointments to dinner reservations. The state’s infrastructure is struggling to keep up with its rapid growth. Commuters in cities like Miami and Orlando face daily traffic snarls, with average commute times exceeding 30 minutes in many urban areas. (Let’s face it, that’s 30 minutes of listening to your favorite podcast or road rage self-help audiobook.)
In Michigan, even in metropolitan areas like Detroit or Grand Rapids, traffic congestion is minimal compared to Florida. The ease of getting around and the availability of public services make life more manageable—and let’s not forget the abundance of parking spaces. Imagine pulling into a lot and NOT having to pray to the parking gods.
Moving From Florida To Michigan
Florida Vs. Michigan Weather
While Florida’s warm weather is a selling point for many, it can also be oppressive. With average summer temperatures hovering around 95°F and humidity levels frequently above 70%, the heat can feel suffocating. Add in the constant battle with mosquitoes, and it’s no wonder some people are ready to escape. Michigan’s four distinct seasons offer a refreshing alternative. Summers are mild, with average highs in the mid-80s and much lower humidity. For those who love a white Christmas or colorful autumn leaves, Michigan delivers seasonal charm in abundance. Plus, no Floridian has ever worn a sweater unironically.
Moving From Florida To Michigan
What's Drawing Floridians To Michigan?
Michigan Cost of Living + Jobs
So what’s drawing people to Michigan? It’s not just the lower cost of living or lack of hurricanes. Michigan has a lot to offer, and some of it might surprise you. While Michigan’s economy has historically revolved around the automotive industry, it’s now diversifying. Tech startups, healthcare, and advanced manufacturing are growing sectors in the state. Ann Arbor, home to the University of Michigan, has become a tech hub, attracting companies like Google and Amazon. Grand Rapids has emerged as a leader in healthcare and life sciences, creating thousands of new jobs. Michigan also has a lower unemployment rate than many states, sitting at 3.8% in 2023, compared to Florida’s 4.1%. For professionals seeking stable careers, Michigan offers plenty of opportunities. Plus, you’re never far from a cider mill or a microbrewery—Michigan has priorities.
Michigan's Lakes
Michigan’s Great Lakes aren’t just for show. With over 11,000 inland lakes and more freshwater coastline than any other state, Michigan is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. Popular activities include boating, fishing, hiking, and skiing. The Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore and Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore are just two examples of Michigan’s breathtaking natural attractions. In addition, Michigan’s vibrant state park system makes it easy for residents to enjoy the great outdoors. The state is also home to several unique natural phenomena, like the northern lights, which can be seen in the Upper Peninsula. And guess what? No gators lurking in the water!
Michigan Community
Michigan offers a strong sense of community and plenty of cultural experiences. From the world-class Detroit Institute of Arts (DIA) to small-town festivals like the National Cherry Festival in Traverse City, there’s always something happening. But let’s take a closer look at Detroit’s cultural contributions, which make it a cornerstone of Michigan’s identity. Detroit’s Arts Scene: Known as the “Paris of the Midwest” during its heyday, Detroit boasts a thriving arts and creative scene. The DIA is one of the top art museums in the country, housing an impressive collection that includes Diego Rivera’s iconic "Detroit Industry Murals." Beyond the DIA, you’ll find the Heidelberg Project, an outdoor art installation that transforms an ordinary neighborhood into a colorful, thought-provoking landscape.
Michigan Music And Entertainment
Music and Entertainment: Detroit is the birthplace of Motown, the legendary record label that brought us artists like Stevie Wonder, Diana Ross, and Marvin Gaye. Visitors can explore Hitsville U.S.A., the original studio where Motown magic was made. Detroit also has a vibrant live music scene, with venues like the Fox Theatre and Saint Andrew’s Hall hosting everything from world-class concerts to up-and-coming bands. (Yes, you too can brag about seeing a band "before they were cool.") Sports and Legacy: Few cities are as passionate about their sports teams as Detroit. Whether it’s cheering on the Lions at Ford Field or catching a Tigers game at Comerica Park, the city’s sports culture is a unifying force. For hockey fans, the Detroit Red Wings represent a storied franchise with a nickname that says it all: "Hockeytown." (Just don’t bring up the Lions' Super Bowl record—or lack thereof. We are on our way though I promise you).
Michigan Food Scene
Culinary Delights: Detroit’s food scene is another gem, offering everything from iconic Coney dogs and Detroit-style pizza to upscale dining experiences. The city’s Eastern Market, one of the largest public markets in the U.S., is a hub for fresh produce, artisan goods, and community events. And let’s not forget the baked goods—because nothing says community like fighting over the last paczki on Fat Tuesday. Cultural Diversity: Detroit’s history as a hub for immigration and migration has created a diverse cultural tapestry. Neighborhoods like Mexicantown, Greektown, and Corktown showcase the city’s rich heritage and culinary variety.
Michigan Festivals And Cultures
Festivals celebrating cultures from around the world are common throughout the year. It’s like taking a world tour without ever leaving the city. Small towns like Frankenmuth, known for its Bavarian-style architecture, and big cities like Detroit, with its vibrant arts scene, give Michigan a unique cultural blend. For those seeking community and connection, Michigan’s welcoming atmosphere is a major draw.
Moving From Florida To Michigan
Michigan Drawbacks
Of course, Michigan isn’t without its drawbacks. The winters can be harsh, with heavy snowfall averaging 60-100 inches in some areas. Heating costs can also be a concern, with the average household spending about $1,200 annually on heating. Additionally, while the state’s property taxes are higher than Florida’s, the overall affordability still tilts the scales in Michigan’s favor. (You’ll still have enough left over for those cider mill donuts.) In the spirit of fairness, let’s also look at why some Michiganders head south to Florida. For many, it’s about escaping those brutal winters.
Florida’s lack of a state income tax is another big draw, saving residents thousands annually. The Sunshine State’s thriving retirement communities and tourism-driven economy also provide unique opportunities for certain demographics. (Plus, snowbirds need somewhere to go!) The migration trend from Florida to Michigan might seem counterintuitive at first, but it’s rooted in practical, real-world considerations. Whether it’s the cost of living, quality of life, or simply the desire for a change of pace, Michigan offers a compelling alternative to life in Florida. So, the next time someone raises an eyebrow at the idea of leaving the Sunshine State for the Great Lakes State, you can tell them: it’s not about leaving paradise—it’s about finding a new one. (And maybe keeping your car insurance premium under control.)
For those who made it this far, why did you move from Florida to Michigan/ And for the people who left Michigan, why did you do it? Drop your thoughts in the comments below!
Thinking of making the move to Michigan? Whether you’re coming from Florida or anywhere else, I’d love to help you find your perfect home in the Mitten State. I also have a link to the Living in Michigan newsletter to give you insight on all things Michigan, so be sure to subscribe so you never miss out! Thanks for reading, until next time.
Cheers,
Andrew
Andrew McManamon is a Michigan REALTOR® with Signature Sotheby’s International Realty and provides real estate services to Buyers, Sellers and Investors throughout SE Michigan including Livingston County, Oakland County, Washtenaw County, Genesee County & beyond. Andrew has become one of the pillars of Michigan real estate. Prior to his real estate career Andrew was responsible for managing a senior living facility in Brighton, Michigan as a dining supervisor and an activities assistant. Andrew’s passion to help people is unlike any other, and he continues to strive to be the best resource he can be. Andrew graduated from Cleary University in Howell, Michigan with a double major in business and marketing, and currently resides in Brighton, Michigan.
Check Out the EXCLUSIVE "Living In Michigan" Apparel HERE
Subscribe to the Living in Michigan Newsletter HERE
Comments